What effect size did Kugel report in 2011?
I don’t have a direct source reporting an effect size that Kugel specifically labeled or calculated in a 2011 publication.
Kugel’s 2011 paper in the Journal of Scientific Exploration [3] is a critical methodological analysis of psychokinesis meta-analyses — it examines and disputes the effect-size calculations reported by other researchers (Radin, Nelson, Bösch, Steinkamp, and Boller) in their PK meta-analyses, but the paper itself is a critique of those analyses rather than a report of Kugel’s own experimental result with an effect size.
If you’re asking about a specific finding or effect size Kugel reported in 2011, the retrieved sources don’t show it. The sources do include Kugel’s 2018 roulette-based precognition work [1], which reported a z-score of +3.27 (p = 0.0006) for the program’s prognosis module, and his earlier roulette studies from the 1990s [6], but not a 2011 effect-size figure.
Could you clarify which study or result you’re asking about? If you can point me to the specific claim or context, I may be able to locate the right source.
References
- Kugel, W. (2018). Amplifying Precognition: Four Experiments with Roulette. Zeitschrift für Anomalistik / Journal of Anomalistics, 18, 214. https://doi.org/10.23793/zfa.2018.214
- Kugel, W. (2013). Essay Review Mythos Hanussen 2001-2011 A collective review Wilfried Kugel 1 Werner Herzog (2001). Zeitschrift für Anomalistik / Journal of Anomalistics, 13, 196.
- Kugel, W. (2011). A Faulty PK Meta-Analysis. Journal of Scientific Exploration, 25.
- Tremmel (2014). Sind außergewöhnliche Erfahrungen lediglich Spontanfälle? Eine Antwort an Michae. Zeitschrift für Anomalistik / Journal of Anomalistics, 14, 292.
- Schneider, C. J. (2014). 189Political ideology…. Zeitschrift für Anomalistik / Journal of Anomalistics, 14, 189.
- European Journal of Parapsychology, volume 8. (n.d.). European Journal of Parapsychology, 8.
More questions answered
- Pool the effect sizes across every ganzfeld study you hold and compare your number to the published Storm and Tressoldi meta-analyses—do they agree?
- Has the effect size for PK data increased in the last 50 years?
- Tell me about the clairvoyance work of the last 50 years
- What trends can you see in precognition research?
- What trends can you see in ESP research in the last 50 years?
- What are parapsychology's current arguments to justify that the phenomena are real and should be taken seriously?